Is your website pretty but useless? Here’s how to tell

Your website looks great.
The fonts are modern. The colours are on-brand. Maybe you even paid a small fortune for stunning photography.

But here’s the million-dollar question:
Is it doing anything?

Because a website that looks good but doesn’t work hard is like a shopfront with no door.

Let’s talk about the signs your website might be all show and no conversion—plus how to fix it.

🚩 1. You’re Getting Traffic… But No Enquiries

You can see people are visiting (thank you, Google Analytics) but no one is clicking, enquiring, or buying.

What it means: Your website might not be guiding people toward a clear next step. Or worse—it’s confusing.

Fix it:

  • Have one clear call-to-action per page

  • Make your contact details and buttons obnoxiously easy to find

  • Ditch the fluff—every word should serve a purpose

🚩 2. You’re Talking About Yourself Too Much

If your homepage starts with “We’re passionate about…” or “Founded in 2006…”, you’ve already lost them.

What it means: You’re making it about you, not your customer.

Fix it:
Flip the script. Speak directly to your audience’s problems and how you solve them.
Use you, not we.
They need to see themselves in your content—or they’ll bounce.

🚩 3. It Looks Great on Desktop… But Clunky on Mobile

More than 60% of website traffic happens on mobile. If your site’s slow, squashed, or glitchy on a phone? You’re losing people before you even start.

Fix it:

  • Test your site on multiple devices

  • Prioritise fast load times and clean layouts

  • Make buttons and forms finger-friendly

👉 Pro tip: Google will also rank you lower if your mobile site sucks.

🚩 4. There’s No SEO Strategy

You’ve got great content. But if it’s not optimised, no one’s finding it.

What it means: You’re invisible to search engines. And if Google can’t find you, neither can your next client.

Fix it:

  • Use keywords your audience is actually searching for

  • Optimise page titles, meta descriptions, and headings

  • Add alt text to images

  • Create content around common questions

🚩 5. There’s No Trust-Building Content

Pretty only gets you so far. People need proof.

Fix it:

  • Add testimonials, reviews, or case studies

  • Show your face (or team) to humanise your brand

  • Include logos of brands you’ve worked with, media features, or certifications

🚩 6. You Don’t Know What’s Working

If you have no idea how people are using your site, where they’re dropping off, or what pages they love, you’re flying blind.

Fix it:

  • Set up Google Analytics and Google Search Console

  • Use heatmaps (like Hotjar) to see what people are clicking on

  • Track conversions: email sign-ups, enquiries, bookings, sales

✅ So... Is Your Website Actually Working?

A great website should:

  • Get found

  • Build trust

  • Guide action

  • Convert visitors into leads, sales, bookings or conversations

If yours isn’t doing that, it’s time for more than just a pretty facelift.

💬 Final Thought

Design matters—but function wins.
A beautiful site that doesn’t convert is like an Instagram model with no substance: fun to look at, but not someone you’d trust with your money.

Let’s turn your “meh” into money-making.

Not sure why your website, socials, or ads aren’t working? With a Digital Marketing Audit, I’ll dig into the data and give you a no-fluff, practical action plan to fix it.

Cristy Houghton

Cristy's unique career has taken her from country NSW to the city lights of Clarendon Street South Melbourne and back again. With an early career in radio as a copywriter and creative strategist, she is now a Jill of all trades as a graphic designer, website builder, blog writer, video editor, social media manager, marketing strategist and more. 

In fact, give her any task and this chick will figure out how to do it! Go on, we dare you!

No, really, we DARE you!!

Cristy has won two Australian Commercial Radio Awards (ACRAs) for Best Ad and Best Sales Promotion, and even has an 'Employee of the Year' certificate with her name on it.

Cristy and her husband James have traveled extensively through Russia, China and South East Asia, and have two fur-babies, Sooty (cat) and Panda (puppy). Cristy loves drinking coffee, meeting people to drink coffee, coffee tasting and coffee flavoured cocktails. She also enjoys road trips, TED Talks and watching cat videos on youtube.

http://www.embarketing.com.au
Previous
Previous

Marketing trends everyone’s talking about (that are actually worth your time)

Next
Next

Steal this: our exact social media caption formula that gets engagement